Q: |
Does the current auditor provide any other services outside of the scope of the RFP?
Posted by:
Peggy Estis
4/15/2024 4:36:13 PM EST
|
A:
|
The City is not aware of any services outside the scope of work.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/16/2024 11:33:17 AM
|
|
Q: |
What has the City budgeted for the services covered in the scope of the RFP?
Posted by:
Peggy Estis
4/15/2024 4:36:52 PM EST
|
A:
|
Currently, no budget has been set.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/16/2024 4:42:59 PM
|
|
Q: |
How many audit adjustments have there been for each of the last three years?
Posted by:
Peggy Estis
4/15/2024 4:37:25 PM EST
|
A:
|
Approximately 5-10 adjustments per year.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/16/2024 4:42:56 PM
|
|
Q: |
Why are you considering a change in auditors?
Posted by:
Peggy Estis
4/15/2024 4:37:49 PM EST
|
A:
|
The contract with the City's previous auditor expires on 09/30/2024. As a Florida municipal corporation, the City of Ocala is required to utilize the auditor selection procedures set forth in section 218.391, Florida Statutes, to select an auditor to conduct its annual financial audit. Those procedures require the issuance of a request for proposal.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/17/2024 10:50:08 AM
|
|
Q: |
We noted fieldwork is to start in February, when will the trial balance and supporting schedules be ready for audit planning and timing purposes?
Posted by:
Peggy Estis
4/15/2024 4:38:26 PM EST
|
A:
|
Approximately January 31, yearly, or usually one week prior to commencement.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/16/2024 4:43:35 PM
|
|
Q: |
What auditor attributes are most appreciated by the City?
Posted by:
Peggy Estis
4/15/2024 4:38:53 PM EST
|
A:
|
Timeliness, accessibility, professionalism, willingness to work with the entire finance team, and is always there to help when we have questions.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/16/2024 4:43:47 PM
|
|
Q: |
1. What EPR/accounting software does the City use? 2. What were the audit fees for the last 3 years? 3. How many major federal programs and state projects does the City anticipate for fiscal year 2024? 4. How many hours of assistance is the City’s internal audit department able to provide the external auditors?
Posted by:
Crystal Bennett
4/15/2024 4:58:41 PM EST
|
A:
|
1. Tyler’s Munis.
2. For a copy of the current audit contract send your request to emarquez@ocalafl.gov
3. Approximately, 30 Federal – 18 State
4. Approximately, our current internal auditors average 600 hours per year.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/16/2024 4:44:20 PM
|
|
Q: |
1. Is the Annual Comprehensive Financial Audit Report required to be ADA compliant?
Posted by:
Omar Daniels
3/26/2024 10:48:25 AM EST
|
A:
|
Yes. Due to Florida Statue 282.601-606 and Section 508, all posted website information must be ADA compliant. The ACFR is required to be posted on our website and is required to be ADA compliant.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 3/27/2024 11:04:04 AM
|
|
Q: |
2. Do you have an internal audit function?
Posted by:
Omar Daniels
3/26/2024 10:49:22 AM EST
|
A:
|
Yes. The City of Ocala has a 3-person internal audit department.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 3/27/2024 11:04:23 AM
|
|
Q: |
3. Have all ARPA funds been expended?
Posted by:
Omar Daniels
3/26/2024 10:50:11 AM EST
|
A:
|
No. All ARPA funds will be obligated as of the next quarterly filing. Which will be reported April 2024.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 3/27/2024 11:04:48 AM
|
|
Q: |
4. Do you prefer for auditors to be on site or to work remotely? Please note that we will be able to attend any public meetings for discussion of the audit report as needed.
Posted by:
Omar Daniels
3/26/2024 10:50:37 AM EST
|
A:
|
Onsite.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 3/27/2024 11:05:10 AM
|
|
Q: |
5. If auditors come onsite, how long are the auditors in the field and how many come?
Posted by:
Omar Daniels
3/26/2024 10:51:24 AM EST
|
A:
|
Currently, we have approximately 6/7 auditors onsite during 4-week filed work. Then, 1-week interim work (summer).
1 – Audit Partner 2 – Audit Directors 1 – Single Audit/Grant Auditor 2/3 – Staff Personal
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 3/27/2024 11:06:13 AM
|
|
Q: |
6. What is the period in which fieldwork is generally performed? Is this still the most convenient time for you?
Posted by:
Omar Daniels
3/26/2024 10:51:51 AM EST
|
A:
|
Fieldwork is performed usually starting the second Monday in February for 4 straight weeks. Interim is performed mid-August for 1-week. Yes.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 3/27/2024 11:06:32 AM
|
|
Q: |
7. What financial software are you currently using? Do you have any plans to change?
Posted by:
Omar Daniels
3/26/2024 10:52:14 AM EST
|
A:
|
We are currently using Tyler Munis; we went live with Tyler in October 2018, and currently have no plans to change.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 3/27/2024 11:06:56 AM
|
|
Q: |
RFP, Tab 1. 3(b) requests a “Sample Audit Report”. Should we upload this as a separate document along with our proposal or can we provide a website link?
Posted by:
Jessica Kelsey
4/9/2024 1:35:34 PM EST
|
A:
|
Please upload as a separate document.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/11/2024 9:30:48 AM
|
|
Q: |
RFP Tab 2.3 requests a copy of sample formats. These sample formats are also included in the “Sample Audit Report” requested in Tab 1.3(b). Is this the same requests or does the City requests the information be provided in both locations?
Posted by:
Jessica Kelsey
4/9/2024 1:36:05 PM EST
|
A:
|
Yes, we are asking for the same request in Tab 1.3(c) as in Tab 2.3. One document depicting all information will work. All reports should be submitted separately. ACFR, DDD, and CRA reports needs to be submitted as separate PDF files that meet ADA compliance requirements to be posted on our City website.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/11/2024 9:31:14 AM
|
|
Q: |
In previous years, the City’s Internal Auditor would provide significant audit assistance. Under this RFP, would the City’s Internal Auditor continue to provide this same level of audit assistance?
Posted by:
Jessica Kelsey
4/9/2024 1:36:22 PM EST
|
A:
|
Yes, the internal auditor provides assistance in areas of Finance including but not limited to search for unrecorded liabilities, CIP projects, inventories, accounts receivable, payroll, and other areas as deemed necessary.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/11/2024 9:31:49 AM
|
|
Q: |
Section 2.3 of your RFP, Insurance Requirements, requires Employee Dishonesty/Fidelity Bond, Inside Money and Securities Coverage in the amount of $1,000,000. However, in addition to the RFP, there is also a link on ProRFx with the City's Standard Insurance Requirements posted. That document does not list this coverage as required. This requirement is unusual and is substantially higher than all other similar engagements. In consideration of the fact that the Audit will not have any “City-owned property in the care, custody or control of the Auditor,” would the City reconsider this requirement or should the additional cost of coverage be included in the proposal.
Posted by:
Jessica Kelsey
4/9/2024 3:36:26 PM EST
|
A:
|
Standard insurance requirements and SPECIAL INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS are listed in the solicitation. Any insurance exceptions shall be evaluated by the City Risk Department.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/11/2024 9:32:25 AM
|
|
Q: |
How many years has the City been using the current auditors?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:08:21 PM EST
|
A:
|
The City has been using the current vendor for over 20 years.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:46:28 PM
|
|
Q: |
What was the City Audit Fee for FY2022 and FY 2023?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:08:44 PM EST
|
A:
|
The City audit fee for FY2022 = $113,646 / FY2023 = $117,624 approximately (FY2023 Audit is not complete).
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:47:27 PM
|
|
Q: |
What was the fee for the ACFR and Report Preparation in FY 2022 and FY 2023?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:09:13 PM EST
|
A:
|
The audit fee for FY2022 = $0.00 / FY2023 = $12,000 approximately (FY2023 Audit is not complete).
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:48:39 PM
|
|
Q: |
What was the fee for the CRA Audit and Report Preparation in FY2022 and FY 2023?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:11:41 PM EST
|
A:
|
The audit fee for FY2022 = $5,175 / FY2023 = $5,355 approximately (FY2023 Audit is not complete).
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:49:47 PM
|
|
Q: |
What was the fee for the DDD Audit and Report Preparation in FY 2022 and FY2023?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:13:30 PM EST
|
A:
|
The fee for the DDD Audit and Report Preparation: FY2022 = $5,000 / FY2023 = $TBD (FY2023 Audit is not complete).
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:51:48 PM
|
|
Q: |
Were there any “out-of-scope” services performed by the current auditor during their tenure? If so, what were the related services and corresponding fees?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:13:44 PM EST
|
A:
|
None that we are aware of.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:52:08 PM
|
|
Q: |
What ERP software is the City currently using? Does the City intend to update their current ERP platform in the near future?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:14:08 PM EST
|
A:
|
Currently, the City of Ocala uses Tyler’s Munis and we do not plan on changing.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:52:28 PM
|
|
Q: |
Please provide a copy of the current audit contract.
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:14:25 PM EST
|
A:
|
For a copy of the current audit contract send your request to emarquez@ocalafl.gov
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:52:50 PM
|
|
Q: |
Please provide a copy of the most recent “Letter to Those Charged with Governance” issued by the auditor.
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:14:39 PM EST
|
A:
|
To request a “Letter to Those Charged with Governance” issued by the auditor, send an email to emarquez@ocalafl.gov
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/16/2024 12:28:54 PM
|
|
Q: |
Does the City plan to issue new debt in the upcoming fiscal year?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:15:03 PM EST
|
A:
|
Not that we are aware of.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:53:16 PM
|
|
Q: |
Has the City completed the FY2023 audit? If so, please make the ACFR available.
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:15:25 PM EST
|
A:
|
The FY2023 audit has not been completed and will be uploaded to the website after it is presented to Council.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:53:44 PM
|
|
Q: |
Does the City’s finance department handle the accounting and record keeping for both the CRA and DDA?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:15:41 PM EST
|
A:
|
Yes, the City finance department handles for both the CRA and DDD.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:54:35 PM
|
|
Q: |
It appears that the FY2022 ACFR was issued on March 30, 2023 and the FY 2022 CRA and FY 2022 DDA were both issued on May 11th. Is it typical for these components to be issued subsequent to the ACFR?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:16:01 PM EST
|
A:
|
No, they are normally issued together, as needed.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:55:01 PM
|
|
Q: |
Page 12 of the RFP states “management personnel available to meet the firms personnel by the 2nd Monday of February of each year” and “the auditor should complete all fieldwork by March 15th.” Are these dates correct? Is the auditor only provided 30 calendar days to complete fieldwork? We ask given the RFP calls for binding agreement of such dates by both parties.
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:16:22 PM EST
|
A:
|
The dates are correct. Currently, the onsite fieldwork last no more than 30 days.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:55:36 PM
|
|
Q: |
Page 16 of the RFP calls for Sample Audit Report (Tab 1 Section 3c) and page 17 of the RFP (Tab 2 section 3) calls for Sample Audit Reports again. Financials of Cities, CRA’s, and DDA’s in the State of Florida are public information published online by the Florida Auditor General. Would a hyperlink to such reports suffice, considering the 40-page proposal limit? Some of these reports, can be hundreds of pages.
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:16:42 PM EST
|
A:
|
Yes, a hyperlink will work as long as the link is to a report the auditor created.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:55:53 PM
|
|
Q: |
Page 19 of the RFP – Evaluation Criteria states the price would be 15 points. We did not identify a weighted average formula for support of such points. Does the City intend to publish a weighted average formula to avoid bias?
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:16:56 PM EST
|
A:
|
The Cost scores are determined by giving the proposal with the lowest total cost the maximum number of points (15 points) allowed. The remaining proposals receive a percentage of the points available based on their cost relationship to the lowest cost proposal. This is determined by applying the following formula:
Price of Lowest Cost Proposal X Maximum points available = Awarded Price Points Price of Proposal Being Rated
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/11/2024 12:26:16 PM
|
|
Q: |
Questions are due by April 15th and a week later the proposals are due (April 22nd). Would the City consider extending the due date, in order to provide sufficient time for the vendors to receive and “digest” the responses to the questions. Such information is critical to compile a vendor proposal.
Posted by:
Moises Ariza
4/10/2024 3:20:47 PM EST
|
A:
|
No, this was originally due back on 4/1.
Posted by:
Eileen Marquez 4/12/2024 2:56:17 PM
|